The Plight of a Georgia Loyalist: William Lyford, Jr. Published in the Fall 2007 Issue of the Georgia Historical Quarterly

 

By J. G. Braddock, Sr.

John Cutler Braddock served admirably in the American Revolution as a patriot, commanding Georgia galleys in fiercely fought battles. His uncle, Capt. William Lyford, Jr., a Loyalist, served just as admirably piloting British warships along the southeastern coast and waterways.[1] Yet historians, while including the exploits of Braddock in a number of postwar writings, rarely refer to Lyford. Only one historian mentioned his wartime service and confined it to a single paragraph extracted solely from his Loyalist claim.[2] Some writers confuse him with his father; just one identified him as a Loyalist and only in indirect terms, saying he was "a devoted British subject banished after the Revolution."[3]This inequity is surprising. Historical records of Lyford, being significantly more abundant than those of Braddock, picture him considerably more interesting than his nephew and indicate that his contributions to Georgia's overall history have been at least as much, if not more.

A painting of a boat in the middle of the night.

Request for Reimbursement

Lyford's quest for at least some reimbursement for the losses his intense loyalty cost him had been a long journey of distance, in expense, and in discouragements from the time and place of those losses. Ten years had passed since the Revolutionary govern­ment confiscated his extensive property in Georgia. In addition to the untold miles he had piloted British warships up and down the southeast coast, he had traveled from Savannah to St. Augustine when banished as a Loyalist, from St. Augustine to Savannah after Savannah's reduction, from Savannah to St. Augustine at the war's end, from St. Augustine to Thunderbolt vainly seeking permission to return to Georgia, from Thunderbolt back to St. Augustine after being refused reentry, from St. Augustine to the Bahamas after the cession of Florida to Spain, and from the Bahamas to London seek­ing a fair settlement of his claim. Not counting the confiscated property valued in his claim at more than nine thousand pounds, he lost ten years of a substantial and steady income operating pilot boats in Savannah and Sunbury, incurred the considerable expense of developing his grants in the Bahamas into inhabitable and farm­able lands, and now had to bear the costs of roundtrip passage to London and subsistence and lawyer fees during his lengthy stay. Not only did he endure the expected discouragements of all dis­placed Loyalists, Lyford also suffered the discouragements of the failure of his original claim submitted three years earlier and of hav­ing to leave his home and family, in his advanced years, to make a long, arduous voyage to England and pound the streets of London day after day seeking memorials and pressing for the settlement of his petition. In early autumn 1787, he received news that added tre­mendously to his weight of woes when he learned a storm had done extensive damage to his property. He told the claims commission that "by the last vessel from New Providence [he] hath received ad­vices that in the hurricane which happened there on the twenty-sev­enth day of August last past, he had the misfortune to have all his buildings blown down, crop destroyed and in general such wreck and devastation in the property he possessed there that he is in dan­ger of having it entirely ruined unless by his presence he shall be capable in some degree to retrieve the losses he hath thereby sus­tained and that upon these accounts his presence in that country becomes absolutely necessary."[35]

Sometime after he made the long voyage back to his home on Cat Island in the Bahamas, the commis­sion considered only £7,157 of his £9,345 claim and granted him a mere £1,000 in settlement.[36]

Except for the official approval of the grant he had received on New Providence earlier, public records have nothing to say of him after his visit to England for almost seven years until the March 14, 1794, issue of the Royal Gazette in Nassau announced his death at the age of seventy-five. The Georgia Gazette repeated the announcement in its March 27 issue.[37] The exact date of his death is not known. In 1996 the internationally famous novelist and res­ident of Lyford Cay, Arthur Hailey, with the help of Cat Island res­ident and educator Eric Moncur, located the ruins of Lyford's house but could not find his gravesite. Ironically, John Cutler Braddock died two months before his uncle and is buried some­where in Glynn County, Georgia, also in an unmarked grave.

Although Lyford's remains still lie in an unmarked grave, his name lives on and is spoken daily by the residents of Lyford Cay, the residential resort at the west end of New Providence Island. In fact, the last book of Arthur Hailey wrote before his death was The Lyford Legacy, a History of Lyford Cay from 1788. The book chronicles how the 448-acre land grant became the residential resort of Ly­ford Cay and how William Lyford's life became part of the region's colorful history.[38]

[1] According to a memo written by Georgia governor James Wright while in exile in Lon­don, Braddock commanded one of the three galleys that ran aground in Amelia Narrows while carrying Continentals to rendezvous with Col. John Baker's militia in East Florida. Allen D. Candler et aI., eds., The Colof receivingords of the State of Georgia, 39 vols. (Atlanta and Athens, Ga., 1904-), vol. 38, pt. 2:124-26. Unpublished volumes in the collection of the Georgia Historical Society, Savannah (hereinafter cited as CRG); "Capt. Braddock" is named as commander of the Lee galley in Col. Samuel Elbert's much-cited letter to Gen. Robert Howe describing the capture of three British warships by three Georgia galleys at St. Simons Island on April 19, 1778. An article in the Royal Georgia Gazette told of a galley commanded by 'John Braddock" and another galley engaging the British brigantine Dun­more in a running battle. Royal Georgia Gazette [Savannah], September 27, 1781. See also, South Carolina and American General Gazette [Charles Town], April 23, 1778. He has brief mentions receiving orders as commander of the Lee in Colonel Elbert's Order Book and in the minutes of Georgia's Executive Council. See William Harden, ed., "Order Book of Sam­uel Elbert, Colonel and Brigadier General in the Continental Army" Collections of the Georgia Historical Society, 22 vols. to date (Savannah, 1840), vol. 5, pt. 2, 123, 186 (hereinafter cited as CGHS); Allen D. Candler, ed. The Revolutionary Records of Georgia, 3 vols. (Atlanta, 1908), 2:92 (hereinafter cited as RRG). Braddock was listed as a traitor in colonial Georgia's Trea­son Act of 1780, Disqualifying Act of 1780, and a list compiled by Loyalist Thomas Flyming of Georgians who "were all of them very active in rebellion against His Majesty in this Prov­ince," RRG, 1 :352; Colonial Book DDD, microfilm, Georgia Archives, Morrow. In addition to his service in the Revolution, he served as an officer in the militia and held several public offices in Glynn County after the war, including two terms in the Georgia Assembly. See Margaret Davis Cate, Our Todays and Yesterdays: A Story of Brunswick and the Coastal lslands (Brunswick, Ga., 1930), 163, 169,231,234,236.

[2] Peter Wilson Coldham, American Loyalist Claims (Washington, D.C., 1980),298-99.

[3] The confusion between father and son is understandable. The two are differentiated in only five of the 158 historical records mentioning them by the inclusion of "Junar," "son of," "younger Lyford," "Junr.," and "my son." Gordon Burns Smith, History of the Georgia Militia, 1783-1861, 4 vols. (Milledgeville, Ga., 2000), 3:36.

[4] "Letters from General Oglethorpe to the Trustees, 1735-1744," CGHS, vol. 5, pt. 1,67; South Carolina Gazette [Charles Town], July 30, 1741, August 30, 1742, January 27 and May 12, 1757, November 20 and December 23,1 758, February 11, 1759; James H. Easterby et al., eds., The Journal of the Commons House of Assembly, 14 vols. (Columbia, S.C., 1951-1989), 4:259; Candler et aI., eds., CRG, 6: 172; Georgia Gazette [Savannah], October 24, 1764. The chart is found in The coast of Florida from the Dry Tortugas to the old Cape by David Cutler Braddock, 1756, Library of Congress, Washington, D.C.

[5] Lawrence S. Rowland, Alexander Moore, and George C. Rogers, Jr., The History of Beaufort County, South Carolina Vol. I: 1514-1861 (Columbia, S.C., 1996), 148.

[6] Colonial Papers, C.O. 23/2:85, British Public Records Office, London; Easterby et al., eds., Journal of the Commons House of Assembly, 1:370-371; South Carolina Governor and Council Journals, sessions of July 13, 15-16,23-24, August 3, September 9, October 8, 11-13, 15, 1742, November 21, December 13, 1743, microfilm, South Carolina Department of Archives and History, Columbia (hereinafter cited as SCDAH); Mendel L. Peterson., The Last Cruise of HMS. Loo (Baltimore, Md., 1955),36-39; South Carolina Gazette, June 23, 1746.

[7] C. A. Linn, ed., Ebenezer Record Book, translated by A. G. Voigt (Savannah, Ga., 1929), 78; Candler et al., eds., CRG, 11:201,303; Colonial BookX2, 727, microfilm, Georgia Archives.

[8] Miscellaneous Records-Charleston County, South Carolina, 114 vols., typescript, 69 A 25, Charleston County Public Library, Charleston; Easterby et aI., eds., Journal of the Commons House of Assembly, 5:354.

[9] Nicholas Olsberg, "Ships Registers in the South Carolina Archives, 1734-1780," South Carolina Historical Magazine 74 (January 1973): 204 (hereinafter cited as SCHM); South Carolina Gazette, October 2, 1756, July 7, 1758, July 30, 1760, January 5, February 27, 1761.

[10] Olsberg, "Ships Registers in the South Carolina Archives, 1734-1780," 251; Judgment Rolls, microfilm, SCDAH; South Carolina Gazette, May 1, 15, June 15, 1762; Pre-Federal Admiralty Court Records Province and State of South Carolina, microfilm, Charleston County Public Library; Mabel L. Webber, ed., "Register of St. Andrews Parish, Berkeley County, South Carolina" SCHM 15 (January 1914): 39.

[11] Olsberg, "Ships Registers in the South Caroline Archives, 1734-1780," 228.

[12] Georgia Commission Book B1-1754-1778, microfilm, Drawer 40, Box 39, Georgia Archives; South Carolina Gazette, February 8, 1768; Georgia Gazette, February 10, 1768; Candler et al., eds., CRG, 14:535-36,562.

[13] Candler et aI., eds., CRG, 10: 669-70, 15: 176-77,498-500; South Carolina Gazette and Country Journal [Charles Town], June 19, 1770. A memorialist is one who presents a petition to a legislative body

[14] Candler et aI., eds., CRG., 38:113-14; Colonial Office Papers, 5/663: MPG357, British Public Records Office.

[15] Georgia Gazette, September 14,20, 1774

[16] American Loyalists Claims, Series II, 1780-1835, AO. 13/36: 500, 516, British Public Records Office; Georgia Colonial Records, Book A-B, 324-27, and Grant Book M, 901, 1014-15, Georgia Archives.

[17] William Bell Clark, ed., Naval Documents of the American Revolution, 9 vols. to date (Washington, D.C., 1968),3:688; "Proceedings of the Georgia Council of Safety, 1775-1777," CGHS,5:67.

[18] American Loyalists Claims, Series II, 1780-1835, AO. 13/36:516.

[19] Thelma Peters, "The Loyalist Migration from East Florida to the Bahamas," Florida Historical Quarterly 40 (October 1961): 127 (hereinafter cited as FHQ); Sherry Johnson, "The Spanish St. Augustine Community, 1784-1795, a Reevaluation," ibid. 68 (July 1989): 33.

[20] Robert Gary Mitchell, "Loyalist Georgia" (Ph.D. diss., Tulane University, 1964), 320.

[21] American Loyalists Claims, Series IL 1780-1835, A.O. 13/36:505-506,508,510.

[22] Ibid., A.O. 13/36:493.

[23] Ibid., A.O. 13/102:1063. The city of Savannah was an important southern objective for the British, and the army sent more than three thousand men to take it. The capture of three British men-of-war in April 1778 by three Georgia galleys, one commanded by John Braddock, followed shortly by another attempted invasion of East Florida, prompted the decision (probably at the urging of the governor of East Florida) to send the troops.

[24] Ibid.

[25] Telemon Cuyler Collection, Box 39, Folder 4, Hargrett Rare Book and Manuscript Li­brary, University of Georgia Libraries, Athens; Pre-l 800 File II, Microfilm, Drawer 202, Box 51, Georgia Archives; Candler, ed. RRG, 2:474-75.

[26] Colonial Office Papers, 23/26:223, British Public Records Office; Royal Gazette [Charlestown, South Carolina], March 20, 1782; Thelma Peters, "The Loyalist Migration," 124; South Carolina Weekly Gazette [Charles Town], May 24, 1783.

[27] Peters, "The Loyalist Migration," 127

[28] South Carolina Weekly Gazette, June 28,1783.

[29] Georgia Gazette, November 17, 1783. .

[30] Mary Moseley, The Bahamas Handbook (Nassau, 1926), 72; Register General Depart­ment of Land Grants-Book AI, 11, Book C1, 185, Book B1, 67, 86-87, Bahamas Department of Archives, Nassau.

[31] Book N, "Schedule of the property of William Lyford, now in Bahamas-March 23," 178, 144, Bahamas Department of Archives; Daniel McKinnen, A Tour through the British West In­dies, in the Years 1802 and 1803, Giving a Particular Account of the Bahama Islands (London, 1812),199.

[32] American Loyalists Claims, Series II, 1780-1835, A. O. 13/36:516; Book N, "List of debts due by Captain Lyford;" Book N, "Schedule of the property of William Lyford, now in Ba­hamas-March 23," 178, 144, Bahamas Department of Archives; American Loyalists Claims, Series II, 1780-1835, A.O. 13/102:1063

[33] American Loyalists Claims, Series II, 1780-1835, A.O. 13/102:1063; American Loyalists Claims, Series I, 1776-1831, A.O. 12/102:83, 88, Bahamas Department of Archives.

[34] American Loyalists Claims, Series II, 1780-1835, A.O. 13/102:504, 514, 1055, 1057, 1059, 1061.

[35] Ibid.,A.O.13/102:1061

[36] Mitchell, “Loyalist Georgia," 344.

[37] Royal Gazette [Nassau, Bahamas], March 14, 1794; Georgia Gazette, March 27, 1794.

[38] Arthur Hailey (1920-2004), The Lyford Legacy, a History of Lyford Cay From 1788 (privately published, c.2003) to raise money for the Lyford Cay Foundation to fund scholarships for Bahamians. Hailey died at Lyford Cay on November 24. This writer furnished Hailey with all the information about Lyford used in the book.